Fantasy Isle Ice Cream in Supply

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream in Supply
5 / 5
50 reviews

3354 Holden Beach Rd SW, Supply, NC 28462-5718, Supply

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
Features
  • Takeout
  • Outdoor Seating
  • Seating
  • Wheelchair Accessible
Good for
  • Large groups
  • Families witd children
  • Kids

Restaurant Hours

Monday

12:00 pm

Wednesday

12:00 pm

Friday

12:00 pm

Sunday

12:00 pm

How much is putt-putt?

Lee is correct! Thanks Lee!😊

How much does it cost to play mini golf there and how much is the average price for the ice cream.

The atmosphere and ice cream are wonderful. Banana split is out of this world and you choose the 3 flavors of ice cream that you want for 6 dollars.

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
ML
Michelle Langford
google
11.21.2024
5/5

Great service and ice cream.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
ES
Erica Smith
google
11.23.2018
5/5

I LOVE this place!! The owners are so sweet and have great service! Very comfortable atmosphere. Very clean and so very well decorated and painted!! You want a good family outing then here is a night of fun! Go Putt Putting then have a delicious waffle bowl of good ice cream! You won't be disappointed!!! Takw it from a lifetime local gal...this is our spot for a night of fun!

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
SP
Shevaun Pastrana
google
11.13.2018
5/5

First time here and they made us feel like we did not want to go anywhere else. They were incredibly friendly and so warm and welcoming. We have 4 kids and they all chose different ice cream flavors and loved them. We will definitely be back!

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
jj
johnny jackson
google
08.22.2018
5/5

Excellent love the icecream on the friendly people that work there and that you can meet ther

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
ST
Supersonic Thrift
google
08.12.2018
5/5

Very friendly people and affordable prices. and the ice cream is awesome!

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
AV
Allen Vaughan
google
08.10.2018
5/5

Homemade ice cream is really good. If you like chocolate ice cream, try the death by chocolate flavor. Putt putt course is also fun.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
AD
Arlene DelBorrello
google
07.11.2018
5/5

We've been coming to Holden Beach for 25 yrs for vacation. Every night we're at Fantasy Isle for ice cream. BEST ice cream on Holden Beach. We talk every day at the beach deciding what flavor we're having tonight.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
KB
Kim Bigley
google
06.01.2018
1/5

This is from an incident on 5/2/2020.Not my experience, however there are photographs of this incident and the owners actions.Shame on the owners of Fantasy Isle ice cream and mini golf ...To think you are BUSINESS owners acting like fools! A small, family wedding approved by the sheriff department, land owner and police department. You have nothing better to do than HARASS a young couple on their special day....this is what we saw from the wedding....Not only were your drunk selves yelling and flipping us off, blaring your music so loudly the whole island could hear it....You had NO respect for the sheriff who came TWICE and had to stay during the SMALL service to you keep you in line....You then PULLED YOUR GUN on an 18 year old....Shame on you....find a hobby.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
MP
Midge Phibbs
google
05.16.2018
5/5

If you're in Holden Beach you MUST stop in for ice cream. It's the atmosphere and their cute, friendly squirrel, Putter, that comes down from the trees to eat a special doll size ice cream cone! That's right, a real squirrel eating a teensy tiny ice cream in a special made waffle cone. They also have a putt-putt course wrapped around the building, great for kids and adults alike. You can also enjoy a swing under the trees or grab a table outdoors. For those wanting air conditioning take a seat indoors where the walls are plastered with photos of previous customers.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
FT
Francis Traver
google
05.10.2018
5/5

Great service and great ice cream. Recommend highly. It's a family tradition when we come to the beach to make at least 1 trip here.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
TC
TONY CARRUBBA
google
05.06.2018
5/5

very clean and minny golf was so safe

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
Emily
google
04.17.2018
5/5

In the past we had gone to another local ice cream shop but this is our new favorite spot! Ice cream is so yummy with many flavors to choose from! Staff and owners are so kind and patient. Will definitely be back!

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
MM
Marcy Medley
google
04.13.2018
4/5

Nice place good ice cream

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
JS
Joshua Smith
google
04.12.2018
5/5

First time visitor to this place and was definitely impressed and pleased....I can see why they have been in business longer than I've been alive. Friendly family atmosphere and staff, very neat and clean facilities, great ice cream at great prices. Add this one to the list of places to visit every time we come to Holden Beach.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
JB
Jean Belmont
google
01.15.2018
5/5

I had a yummy no sugar added toasted almond cone! Hubby had a Rocky Road.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
JG
John Gray
google
01.06.2018
5/5

Wonderful place. Friendly, competent service. Have been going for many years Ice cream and mini golf and a great place to sit and relax.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
Bill
google
11.21.2017
5/5

Still the best at Holden but prices have gone up a bit since last year. Friendly, courteous staff. Great to sit on the porch under the live oaks and just kick back awhile.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
RH
Ryan Huffstutler
google
11.08.2017
5/5

Love this place! The staff are always very friendly and the ice cream is fantastic. Always on the to do list when we stay at Holden Beach!

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
JL
Jeffrey Long
google
10.21.2017
5/5

This is a semi challenging course that is laid out under a massive tree. That tree is home to the main attraction of this establishment. Putter is a squirrel that lives in the tree and it comes down to eat a small cone of peanut ice cream everyday. The owners are amazing people. They are so kind to all kids that visit and are all around good people. My wife, son, and I love coming to play mini golf and enjoy a delicious waffle cone and ice cream. They have an ingredients list for every flavor of ice cream they serve readily available. Frankly, this is a place that my family will visit as often as we can.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
SS
Sara Smith
google
10.03.2017
5/5

Had a blast. Simple but kept up well. Great ice cream and friendly staff. Loved the outdoor scenery and seating under the live oak trees.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
Jw
Jade worley
google
07.20.2017
5/5

We had a such a good time! We played mini golf and then got ice cream. The mini golf course was so much better than expected and they even have bug spray out for customers use! They have lots of ice cream flavors to choose from and the environment is very welcoming. Highly recommend this place for your mini golf and ice cream needs while vacationing!!

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
TC
Tyler Cranford
google
07.07.2017
5/5

Great people really care about all their customers! Everything was well maintained.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
SM
Shannon Mclain
google
06.25.2017
5/5

We stayed at a different beach and the place we were at was closed for the season so we drove to Holden Beach to go to another that was closed also. We just stumbled on this gem by pure luck. Great staff made you feel right at home. Best ice cream we will go back again.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
Haliec_27
google
06.22.2017
5/5

This is the best place I have ever been too! I haven't been as happy as I was there in almost 3 years. Mrs.Pam the owner is one of the friendliest ladies on earth. She is so kind and loving. Everyone should go there!! Its amazing💜

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
KN
Karen Nelson
google
05.22.2017
5/5

Love this place!! Best ice cream and homemade waffle cones. Have been coming here for 20 plus years and will keep coming back!!

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
BD
Brooke Dylan
google
05.17.2017
5/5

Love this place too, been coming here since I was a kid now I bring my family.. We even have pic on the walls too.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
ct
chris turner
google
05.15.2017
5/5

Great place. Very nice staff. Putt putt is nice, well kept, but the holes are not too difficult.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
TB
Tiernay Bookless
google
04.14.2017
5/5

Great family oriented staff. Allot of fun to visit after a day at the beach.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
SE
Saundra Everhart
google
03.18.2017
5/5

Delicious handmade icecream. Try the lemon...unbeleaveable scrumptious. 🍋

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
TM
Tammy Mancini
google
03.08.2017
5/5

Best place in town for ice cream.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
LD
Luis De Mendoza
google
03.06.2017
5/5

Every year we come to Holden Beach with the family and every year we go play putt putt and eat ice cream at Fantasy Isle.Now in truth the course isn't anything too amazing or intricate, but don't let that stop you from visiting and making it like a good golf event. We come and let the kids putt around even though they take a dozen swings. It's funny to watch. Then the adults try and sober up and channel their inner Tiger Woods to beat each other.We've come before when no one is here and we've come when the wait is long, but there is tons of seating around and everyone always seems happy here.The ice cream inside is good. It you are unsure of what to get an employee will give you samples and you can choose from a cup or a few different cones.Then you can sit inside in the AC or outside on the swing or some of the chairs laid around. Prices are pretty cheap for everything and it's a great family place.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
PC
Pat Clark
google
02.23.2017
5/5

It was fantastic. Ice cream is delicious. Golf was fun with grandson.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
NW
Neil W. Hart III
google
02.21.2017
5/5

Love this place!!! Came here as a child and now I can bring my children here for ice cream and mini golf. I love it!

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
AS
Amy Sheppeck
google
02.09.2017
5/5

Absolutely Love Fantasy Isle! The owners Scott and Pam are always fantastic and welcoming. The staff is always helpful and super nice. Mini Golf is well maintained and so much fun! If you get a chance to go in the fall I recommend Haunted Mini Golf. We try to get there every year❤️

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
MS
Melanie Shull
google
01.26.2017
5/5

We visited Fantasy Island for our first time this week. The owner was so nice and really gave us our money’s worth. We went back the next time they were open.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
AB
Andrew Brock
google
01.18.2017
5/5

Great miniature golf and fantastic ice cream. The service was wonderful.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
ES
Ethan Smith
google
01.05.2017
5/5

One of my favorite places to visit at Holden Beach. The mini golf course is well kept and fun. The ice cream is delicious, and you have to get a waffle cone. They are the reason to come here. Also the staff are very nice and friendly to talk to. Cannot recommend this place enough.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
GT
Greg Thompson
google
11.19.2016
5/5

We had a really good time here. Owner was extremely polite making sure we had everything we needed on a hot day. Very reasonable for an afternoon of mini golf and ice cream. The old trees make for a great venue to cool off in the shade.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
CH
Cynthia Hicks
google
10.22.2016
5/5

Thanks Scott and Pam for a fun carpet golf and ice cream experience. Ayden loved hunting eggs and visiting with the Easter bunny. Relaxing experience on the causeway...

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
Ld
Lisa den Blanken
google
07.08.2016
3/5

The ice cream was a bit expensive. Staff was sadly not very friendly. Maybe she had an off day. Did not try the fudge but it looked great.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
AS
Alec Stowe
google
06.15.2016
5/5

Love this place. The staff is always very friendly, and the outside seating is awesome. The mini golf is a nice touch and everything is fairly priced. I visit every time I'm in holden.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
NH
Natasha Harper
google
05.18.2016
5/5

The icecream was awesome! It tasted so good. The employees were great also!

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
SW
Stacy Whitfield
google
05.15.2016
5/5

Had a blast w the family. Great Ice Cream and the people working were just SUPER SWEET!! THANKS FOR A GREAT TIME!!

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
SW
Sydney Wiggins
google
05.11.2016
5/5

Been going here since I was 5. Now I go with my husband and child. Never disappoints! The new owners are super nice and always make you feel right at home. Ice cream is second to none and it really does have the best mini golf course at Holden.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
RT
Riven Terrik
google
04.26.2016
5/5

The ice cream scoops were very large which interesting flavors and the put put was well put together and fun.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
PG
Pablo Gonzalez
google
04.25.2016
5/5

Great ice cream, the best mini golf in town, and the stuff are always super friendly. The cones are hand made and fresh.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
CM
Caitlynn McManus
google
04.12.2016
5/5

So family friendly! The staff was so kind. They joked with us about loving the Gamecocks so much then played the gamecock song in the store for us! The icecream is so good as well. The golf was simple and entertaining. We definitely will be going back.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
AL
Ana Lustig
google
03.17.2016
5/5

Very charming place. The mini golf is a fun course and the I've cream is delicious! A definite must-do if you're in Holden Beach.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
Amy
google
02.12.2016
5/5

Cute place. Very fun mini golf. People there are extremely friendly.

Fantasy Isle Ice Cream
ES
Eric Smith
google
01.03.2016
4/5

What a neat place, grate ice cream, shaded mini golf. Can't wait to go again.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 19108424008

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!